Flight Simulator Rankings
5 years 11 months ago #15119
by jer029
Flight Simulator Rankings was created by jer029
<div>Out of curiosity I looked over eight recent reviews of the most popular flight simulators. I was a bit surprised by the results, particularly that P3D rarely shows up on the list. I tallied up the choices for 1-2 place and then for 1-3 place. In both cases the results were the same. I combined Xplane-10 and Xplane-11, and FSX and FSX-Steam to single categories. The complete breakdown is listed at the bottom.</div>
<div> </div>
<div>
Anyway, here's the results I came up with:</div>
<div>1. X-Plane
2. FSX
3. Virtual Pilot 3D</div>
<div>
Detailed breakdown:
</div>
<img src="ranking.jpg" alt="" width="414" height="399"><br /><br /><!-- editby --><br /><br /><em>edited by: jer029, Feb 26, 2019 - 10:44 AM</em><!-- end editby -->
<div> </div>
<div>
Anyway, here's the results I came up with:</div>
<div>1. X-Plane
2. FSX
3. Virtual Pilot 3D</div>
<div>
Detailed breakdown:
</div>
<img src="ranking.jpg" alt="" width="414" height="399"><br /><br /><!-- editby --><br /><br /><em>edited by: jer029, Feb 26, 2019 - 10:44 AM</em><!-- end editby -->
Please Log in to join the conversation.
5 years 11 months ago #15120
by SPA031
Replied by SPA031 on topic Flight Simulator Rankings
What were the reasons?
Please Log in to join the conversation.
5 years 11 months ago #15121
by jer029
Replied by jer029 on topic Flight Simulator Rankings
<div>Generally:
</div>
<div>- Most realistic
- Accurate ATC system and navigation
- Complete instrument flying and approaches
- Advanced navigation including NDB, VOR, ILS and GPS
- Fly a real airline route on autopilot
- Good Animation
- Good Storyline/gameplay
- Most recommended among fans of the genre
</div>
</div>
<div>- Most realistic
- Accurate ATC system and navigation
- Complete instrument flying and approaches
- Advanced navigation including NDB, VOR, ILS and GPS
- Fly a real airline route on autopilot
- Good Animation
- Good Storyline/gameplay
- Most recommended among fans of the genre
</div>
Please Log in to join the conversation.
5 years 11 months ago #15122
by SPA031
Replied by SPA031 on topic Flight Simulator Rankings
Where does P3D V4 fail?
Please Log in to join the conversation.
5 years 11 months ago #15124
by jer029
Replied by jer029 on topic Flight Simulator Rankings
Yikes Robert,
I only did a cursory Internet search to come up with 8 different ratings. I wasn't able to interview them about it.
I'm surprised too - and have no answer to that question. I would have expected P3D to be high on the list, being one of the first 64-bit sims available.
It would seem that VR simulation is the next big step - and many 3rd party addons are already working on development for that technology. This would make 64-bit a mere footnote as technology continues to advance.
I only did a cursory Internet search to come up with 8 different ratings. I wasn't able to interview them about it.
I'm surprised too - and have no answer to that question. I would have expected P3D to be high on the list, being one of the first 64-bit sims available.
It would seem that VR simulation is the next big step - and many 3rd party addons are already working on development for that technology. This would make 64-bit a mere footnote as technology continues to advance.
Please Log in to join the conversation.
Time to create page: 0.075 seconds